This series of posts is aimed at you, the intermediate driver. Let’s identify and fix some common errors. If you’re not an intermediate driver, just know that you can become one if you try hard enough.
If there’s one defining flaw of the intermediate driver, it’s too much emphasis on the phrase in slow, out fast. This leads to several related problems, which I’ll be discussing in the next couple posts.
The problem with threshold braking
Remember those days when you were afraid to hit the brakes hard? Probably not. Your mind was so full of the track that you were barely aware of what your limbs were doing. There was no spare attention for self-assessment. I’m guessing that like a lot of novices, you coasted into your braking zones. We all did at one point. But not anymore! Your car brakes so well it feels like your eyes are going to pop out of their sockets. Once you get a little experience, you start to feel the fun in braking. There are more Gs in braking than there are in accelerating or cornering. While threshold braking is a skill that is important to master, it may also be holding you back. We all know that exit speed is the key to a corner. But what you might not appreciate is that the entry speed determines the exit speed. However, that comes with some risk.
Exiting a corner on the limit is like tightrope-walking; entering a corner on the limit is like jumping onto a tightrope while blindfolded –Mark Donohue
There is an ideal speed at the entry that maximizes the exit speed. Too slow and the corner is ruined. Too fast and you may end up off track. Most drivers recognize that too slow is a lot safer than too fast and therefore drive too slow. Now let’s imagine you have a blindfold on and there is a rope in front of you and you are forced to walk it. Are you going to jump blindly or inch forward to feel where it is? The more time you take to inch forward, the more likely it is you’ll find the rope and have some success walking it. And so it is with entry speeds. The more time you give yourself to feel the entry speed, the more you’ll be able to maximize it without going too far over. The problem with aggressive braking is that it robs you of the time you’re allowed to probe. To get more experience in optimizing your entry speed, you need to spend more time sensing it, thinking about it, and adjusting to it.
The exercise: triangular brake pressure
In the figure below, I’ve loaded up some demonstration laps from Assetto Corsa into Race Studio Analysis. The blue line is hard braking while the red line is soft braking. Note how much higher the blue traces are than the red. They are also much more rectangular in shape. That’s not only because the top is flat, but the sides are vertical. This is using the brake as an on/off switch. For the exercise, I want you to make your brake pressure triangular. Build it up and then trail it off. Yeah, this is exactly what some instructor told you not to do at one point. Go slowly enough that you can spare the attention to your braking foot.
Try to build up your entry speed by braking less and less. However, the goal isn’t to stop braking but to stop over-braking. Drag your brake through the corner entry and you will feel the steering wheel start self-centering. This is a kind of tactile speedometer that your hands will learn to read. My favorite reason to trail-brake isn’t rotation but speed-sensing. A relaxed grip will help you in this endeavor.
U-shaped speed trace
If you’re rolling more speed through the corner entry, your speed traces will have U-shaped bottoms (red) rather than V-shaped bottoms (blue). A V-shape indicates an abrupt change in speed. That typically happens if you mash one pedal and then the other. If you’re holding speed, the speed trace is much more gradual in descent.
But wait, there’s more
In the graph above, one thing you may notice is that the red laps are more consistent than the blue laps. It’s easier to drive when the car isn’t being yanked fore and aft. The red laps are also faster by about 1 second. If you counted up how many lines there are, you would also observe that there are 10 blue lines and 11 red ones. That’s because soft brakes increased fuel economy by 10%. Can it really be true that braking softer results in faster laps, less wear, increased economy, and more consistency? Yes, but don’t take my word for it, try it yourself.
So when do you go back to threshold braking? Is never okay? Yes, I think it is. By giving yourself more time to set the ideal entry speed, you’re on the path to advanced driving techniques (like zero steer). Mashing the brake pedal leads to flat-spotted tires, understeer, bad decisions, and remaining an intermediate driver forever.
8 thoughts on “Intermediate Topic #2: brake pressure”
I really enjoy your insights and the way you pick things apart like a high school physics experiment. You seem to connect with my “inner egghead”.There are definitely some things that have really clicked for me through your blog and have allowed me to go faster.
Thanks, that’s one of the nicest things anyone has said about the blog.
I agree that soft triangular braking (with upswing sharper than downswing) is superior to rectangular braking. But…
1) it is important to establish that a rectangular tracing isn’t due to clipping (by comparing max pedal pressure with max graphed pressure)
2) optimal shape of pressure depends on turn type. The slower the corner, the more the tracing should look like a triangle.
3) threshold braking combined with triangle braking is likely faster than soft triangle or threshold square – it’s just hard to achieve. I accept that the target audience is intermediate drivers but it’s worth noting.
In turns with less speed change (faster corners) I believe optimal brake tracing is still triangular but slower onset. Soft on and off.
It’s nice to find another person passionate about braking. When I tell people that braking is the most important thing, most people look at me like I’m crazy. It’s exit speed dude. No, no it’s not.
Yes, I remember telling a non-racer that braking was my favorite part of tracking. Blank stare. So funny how they always ask, “how fast did you go?”
I feel that braking is by far my biggest weakness as an intermediate driver. One thing that I’ve struggled with since switching to a momentum car is that – in order to successfully trail brake for rotation, a skill that I’m developing – I’ve got so little available brake to use.
That sounded a little odd. Basically, on a mythical corner that I should be taking at 60, if I’m now coming in at 75 instead of my previous 100 I’m finding it really challenging not to overbreak, and even more so to brake late/hard enough to be meaningful but still have “left over” braking to use for trail braking.
Any advice? Did that even make sense as a question?
Sense made. The more powerful the car, the more time is spent on brakes. So in a momentum car, there is less braking time in general. If you’re used to braking for 2 seconds and the corner only takes 1 sec, that could definitely throw you off. Try braking a lot softer.